Movie Rating: Wine (Check out the movie ratings scale on the top left pane of the page)
In Short: Frankly, not enough material here to be made into a movie. Over-rated; but the cinematography was quite good.
The latest fare from Danny Boyle, the director of ‘Slumdog Millionaire’ and ‘Trainspotting’, did not impress me too much, although there seems to be a lot of buzz surrounding this one. Without any disrespect to the person who this movie is based on, there was frankly not enough material within this movie to keep me engaged through its entire length. After all, watching a mountain climber stuck in a crevice by a boulder for 127 hours, does not truly make great premise for a movie story. I do acknowledge that it would be a difficult job for any director, to make this into an engaging and interesting watch, and thats where the movie fails.
That being said, the movie did have good cinematography and visuals, and James Franco (the lead actor) did do a rather good job of conveying how it would be for a person (both physically & mentally) being stuck up in a desolate place for so long. The oscar nomination for A.R. Rahman for providing the score for this film, should also keep Indian audiences cheered up and excited for a while.
In my opinion there have been some better accident related / trapped movies, which have made for a more interesting watch. These include “Alive” (based on a rugby team stuck in the Andes after their plane crashed), “Open Water” (based on a couple who accidentally get left behind in shark-infested waters on a scuba trip), and “Frozen” (based on a group of friends stuck in a ski lift).
So watch this one only if you are a big Danny Boyle fan, or for that matter an A.R. Rahman fan.